Tale of a Big-Boned Gal

Story of a woman undergoing gastric bypass surgery.

Friday, February 16, 2007

Commen-Tater

I received a couple of comments on the Super Bowl blog from some folks who seemed upset at the use of particular word.

“It is too bad you chose words like fag and faggot in this post-maybe you should be more cognizant of who might be reading....
As an overweight or fat, obese, beefy*, big, blimp, brawny, broad, bulging, bulky, bull, burly, butterball*, chunky*, corpulent, cow, distended, dumpy, elephantine, fleshy, gargantuan, gross, heavy, heavyset*, hefty, husky, inflated, jelly-belly*, lard, large, meaty*, obese, oversize, paunchy, plump, plumpish, ponderous, porcine, portly, potbellied, pudgy*, roly-poly*, rotund, solid, stout, stubby, swollen, thickset*, tubby, weighty, whale person, you know all too well the negative thoughts and feelings hatred and bigotry cause. Your wording expresses this to gay people. I guess you get the drift...
Very disappointing for someone who has probably faced their own discrimination issues.
You stated that you enjoyed Princes' peformance, why didn't you call him a fag too?
His stage which is a sacred symbol to him; represents the integration of male and female sexuality.
Chose your expression carefully as you ARE on the World Wide Web.”

Okay first of all I need to address the intent in which I used the word “fag” (and by the way I never used the word “faggot” as the commenter states). The thing is, I always use that word to describe even manly men as well as gay men. I have known and been friends with, and hung out with, and been in love with, and danced with, and lent money to, and been in car accidents with so many gay men in my life, I think it would surprise even the haggiest of fag-hags. The comment was not meant in a harmful way, and I was not by any means demeaning anyone of the gay persuasion. For that, I apologize.

Sometimes I think we get hung up on words and their meanings and the intentions in which they are used. It’s just the way I am – it’s why I call Greg "a bastard” or my sister’s family “hillbillies” or my nephew “honey.” I have nothing against bastards or hillbillies, it's just words I use.

And then there’s the question of using the word “retard.” Now most people think that’s a cruel moniker for a person who is mentally challenged. For me, having taken care of my mentally retarded aunt for 20 of the last 30 years, I feel like I’m entitled to use that word. I would sometimes call her a retard, but it never hurt her feelings…

I have been called most of the names the reader mentioned (you left out "Jabba" and "Sta-Puft") but you know what, maybe I was all those things. Maybe I’m still some of them, but I don’t care. It’s someone else’s problem. I’m over it. (thanks for putting those in alphabetically order by the way so I can easily file them for later when I get skinny and can make fun of fat people too).

Actually it’s too bad that this person is nitpicking my tiny little insignificant blog, when there are SO many sites on the world wide web that are there solely for the purpose of persecuting groups of people, created by narrow-minded boobs who view those they hate as "different."

I’m impressed with the reader’s passion and I am just as passionate about these issues. See my friend Greg’s blog on the subject here. It’s a mean world and we can’t change it overnight. We can only be careful and kind in and of ourselves and hope some of it rubs off on others. And the reader is right, using hateful words in any forum sometimes fosters those prejudices.


And maybe Prince is a fag too. That’s okay with me.

6 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, did you call me a bastard?!? Those of us born out of wedlock can't help that fact. It's not our fault our parents couldn't keep their hands off each other! Anyway that's what I've been told from people who are bastards :-).

Apparently the commentor didn't read the title of your blog. You're not husky, you're big boned. And what a big chicken they were. "Anonymous said..."??? WTF? No web address or e-mail or anything. Apparently not interested in dialog that might further understanding and change behavior, just an anonymous criticism. What a fag.

7:13 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa! My only thought is does the "person" only refer to people as "that person over there"? Maybe I don't want of be thought of as a red-head, woman, bitch, nurse, whitie, cracker, tall, wide. We as humans MUST catagorize things - it's the only way we can make sense of our world - for crying out loud, I organize my M&M before I eat them. Just beacuse I point out to my frined, "the fag standing over there" doesn't mean I hate that person or think he shouldn't be a fag. It may be the only distinguishing characteristic apparent at the time. Words are words - and at some point in time some one got scard of them so now we are all expected to be frightened by them (words that is, not worms, Roxanne).
My grandma called Brazil nuts "nigger toes" her whole life. (Not to demean anyone - she called niggers "colored-people") but because that is what she learned - not how she felt. I'm realitivly sure she never had a desire to eat the pedal digits of an Africian-American.

There are noe people saying Barak O. is not REALLY an African-American. Enough all ready!!!!

So, my advice, unbunch your undies, stiffen up your lip and stop being such a fag.

8:28 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

By the way - I posted comment #3 as anonymous because I didn't want to spend the time setting up an account - It's Rachel!!! So shut up!

8:29 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Certain words show insecurities of many
When we use homophobic words and slurs we are being insensitive to ourselves as well as others.

Certain things we say can often have harmful and unintended consequences. An example of this is the use of words like “fag” and “gay” when putting someone down or describing something as stupid.

I frequently hear the word “fag” being used to put down and criticize other people. There seems to be an inherent irony in this. Frequently, this word is used when one man tries to assert his masculinity and “straightness” by calling into question the sexuality of another. This insult carries a lot of weight. If two men are comfortable with their straight sexual orientation, homosexuality doesn’t need to be feared, and using the word “fag” does not become an insult. Essentially, calling someone a fag or gay shows an insecurity in your own sexuality and shows a need to define it by saying, “I’m not gay, you are gay and that makes me straight.” Insults aren’t the only way homophobic remarks have made their way into common dialogue. A frequent cringe-inducing phrase I hear goes something like this: “God, that is so gay.” I understand that the word is meant to be a synonym for bad, stupid. The rationalization is that homosexuality embodies these things. Using the word in this way makes no sense. Any standard dictionary will say that “gay” has two meanings: happy and homosexual, usually referring to men. Just like using the word “fag” to insult someone, labeling things as gay reflects an unjustified fear of homosexuality. These words being used in homophobic contexts reflect an obsession our society has with sexual orientation. The truth is, you never can really know a person’s sexual orientation until you ask them, so it seems odd when I hear gossip and discussion regarding a person’s sexuality. People seem to think they can put people’s traits into categories to determine their sexual orientation; a girl with masculine traits or interests might be a lesbian, and likewise, a man with feminine traits or interests might be gay. A good example of this is when my own sexual orientation comes under question because I enjoy cooking. I always like to point out the ridiculousness of these statements by saying, “So it’s by a person’s enjoyment of cooking that we determine sexual orientation?” If you’re happy and content with your own sexuality, it makes no sense to be afraid of the sexualities of others. The basis for understanding anyone, yourself included, is working through and overcoming irrational fears. Using accusative, homophobic slurs only serves to promote an atmosphere of fear and intolerance. Rather than worrying about the sexualities of others, worry about your own and think about what you’re really saying the next time you make a homophobic remark or insult.

1:58 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

So are cigarettes homosexual or happy? They get called fags, too!

See words are just that - WORDS!! Get over it and, by the way, get over yourself (all ya'all).
We are all lots of things. If someone calls me a white, cracker, Bible-thumping, ignorant, dike, piece of poor white trash, or a fat, nigger, faggy, atheist, whore - it doesn't matter. Maybe I'm all of those things and maybe I'm none - calling me a name doesn't change WHO I am - or MAKE me that. Neither should it cause me to lapse into some sort of emotional state which will cause my self esteem to disappear into the black hole of bigotry

Perhaps, if we could manage to be half as secure in our own personhood as we pretend to be - - we would find that, in fact, words will never hurt us. I have to go now and figure out why people would call me white AND black...

By the way, if “Anonymous” cringes at the phrase, “God, that is so gay.” He/she will HATE this one, “Some of my best friends are gay” (and it’s true – the only fag-hag bigger than me is Annette!!) As Stephen Colbert would say – leave God out of this He’s straight!

Thanks, Annette, the dance before the Super Bowl was a bit fag-ish!! (No, I don't mean they were smoking!)

Rachel

4:27 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Maybe you think words are just words which is easy for you to say-as you have never been a victim of a hate crime that began with WORDS.
Remember Matthew Shepard?
Here is an example of more hateful words.
MATTHEW SHEPARD FOUNDATION CONGRATULATES DAVID STERN AND THE NBA FOR THEIR LEADERSHIP IN HELPING ERASE HATE

NBA REPRESENTATIVE FIRED FOR HATEFUL REMARKS

Casper, WY - The Matthew Shepard Foundation applauds David Stern and the National Basketball Association for taking swift and appropriate action against former Miami Heat Player and NBA representative, Tim Hardaway. Mr. Hardaway demonstrated blatant promotion of hate during an interview on 790 The Ticket when he stated that he "hate(s) gay people" and was admittedly homophobic.

"I am personally thankful that Mr. Stern and the NBA demonstrated strong leadership in how they dealt with this situation. These actions send a strong message that 'hate' directed at any member of our society is not acceptable," said Judy Shepard, Executive Director of the Matthew Shepard Foundation.

Longstanding homophobia within the sports community has recently become more apparent to the public because of Mr. Hardaway's inexcusable comments and the remarks of NFL players who were a part of the Snickers Superbowl campaign, which the Matthew Shepard Foundation strongly condemned.

"Hate is a learned behavior. Our sports heroes (and all people)have a responsibility to send positive messages to our younger generation to teach them that hate is unacceptable." concluded Shepard.

The Matthew Shepard Foundation was founded by Dennis and Judy Shepard in memory of their 21-year-old son, Matthew, who was murdered in an anti-gay hate crime in Wyoming in October 1998. Created to honor Matthew in a manner that was appropriate to his dreams, beliefs and aspirations, the Foundation seeks to "Replace Hate with Understanding, Compassion & Acceptance" through its varied education, outreach and advocacy programs. For more information, please visit www.MatthewShepard.org

There is no shortage of hateful words that lead to even-yes murder.

Thanks for thinking-that was the intention. This is not a funny issue words are the root of hate and it spreads. The results are unacceptable.
This is just a call to awareness for all people to think before you speak and to project positive wordage into the world.
Maybe if there was more care given to the power of words Mathew Shepard would still be alive.

8:47 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home